Ranking the Ten Events by Real-Life Payoff
You have taken the Intellectual Decathlon, recorded your results, and built a profile of your strengths and weaknesses. The next question is practical: where should you spend your study time?
Ten events is a lot to prepare for, and they do not pay off equally. Some train skills you use every week when you read the news, weigh a medical risk, or evaluate a sales pitch. Others train tasks whose practice gains don't spread much beyond the task itself, or skills that matter mainly in particular jobs.
The short answer: for most adults, the two events most worth preparing for are statistical and probabilistic reasoning (Event 9) and logical reasoning (Event 2). Reading comprehension, mathematical reasoning, and scientific reasoning come next. Working memory and processing speed are the least worth drilling.
Treat this as a practical judgment, not a research-measured ranking. The evidence behind it is uneven, and your own goals may change the order.
This article explains that ranking, shows the criteria behind it, and describes when the answer changes for you.
If you have not yet taken the decathlon, start with the main article: The Intellectual Decathlon: Ten Tests of Mental Ability (With a Preparation Guide).
Three Criteria for Real-Life Payoff
"Most useful" is easy to assert and hard to defend. To keep the ranking checkable, each event is judged on three questions:
Use: How often does the skill matter in ordinary decisions about health, money, work, citizenship, and the claims people make to you?
Trainability: Does performance actually improve with study, and how quickly?
Transfer: Do the gains carry beyond the practice questions to new problems and real situations?
An event earns a high rank only if it does well on all three. A skill's importance alone doesn't set its priority. How much it improves with study, and how far the gains carry beyond the test, matter just as much.
The evidence on these questions is uneven: strong for some events, thin for others. Where research runs out, the ranking relies on practical judgment about relevance and likely benefit per hour of study.
Skill, not test. This article ranks the value of building the skill behind each event, not of rehearsing the test itself. The studies cited below trained skills such as statistical reasoning and argument analysis; none tested whether preparing for the Berlin Numeracy Test or the LSAT, as such, improves real-life decisions. Use the tests to find where you stand, then choose instruction that fits your goals.
The Ranking at a Glance
| Event | Real-Life Payoff | Main Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 9. Statistical Reasoning | Highest | Widely used; key methods transfer |
| 2. Logical Reasoning | Highest | Every argument you hear; good evidence |
| 3. Reading Comprehension | High | Valuable everywhere; target your bottleneck |
| 4. Mathematical Reasoning | High | Money and work math; big gains if rusty |
| 6. Scientific Reasoning | High | Judging health and research claims |
| 5. Verbal Reasoning | Moderate | Vocabulary helps; overlaps with Event 3 |
| 7. Spatial Reasoning | Situational | Very trainable; matters most in technical work |
| 1. Abstract Reasoning | Low | Puzzle practice transfers poorly |
| 8. Working Memory | Lowest | Gains stay close to the drill |
| 10. Processing Speed | Lowest | Little evidence of broad benefit |
| Bonus: Divergent Thinking | Modest | Training helps; transfer is uncertain |
The tiers matter more than the exact order within them.
Tier 1: Statistical and Logical Reasoning
Event 9: Statistical and Probabilistic Reasoning
Why it ranks first. Few skills come up as often in decisions that matter. A doctor tells you a screening test is 90% accurate. A news story says a food raises cancer risk by 50%. A financial adviser shows you last year's returns. A poll puts a candidate ahead by three points. Each of these calls for the same small set of ideas: base rates, conditional probability, sample size, and the difference between relative and absolute risk.
The Berlin Numeracy Test used in the decathlon was developed for exactly this purpose: to measure risk literacy, the ability to understand and act on information about risk.1
Trainability and transfer. This is where Event 9 stands out. Statistical reasoning is one of the few thinking skills with good evidence that short, focused instruction transfers to everyday problems. In a classic series of experiments, brief training on the law of large numbers increased both how often and how well people reasoned statistically about a wide range of everyday-style problems, and the benefits of formal statistics training appeared even when people were tested outside the classroom setting.2 These were reasoning problems, not real decisions, so the studies show transfer across problem types rather than proof of better health or financial choices.
Bayesian reasoning, the kind needed to interpret a positive medical test, is notoriously hard. But in experiments with computer tutorials lasting under two hours, people learned to solve such problems. Both training in the formula and training that translated probabilities into natural frequencies ("10 out of every 1,000 people") transferred to new problems; the natural-frequency method produced stronger immediate learning and lasted longer.3
Where to start:
Learn to build a frequency tree. Start with, say, 1,000 people; split them into those with and without the condition; then split each group by test result. Keeping the groups separate is what makes base-rate problems solvable.
Whenever you see a relative risk ("50% higher"), ask for the absolute numbers ("from 2 in 10,000 to 3 in 10,000").
Practice base-rate problems until you can sketch the tree without looking up the method.
Before trusting a striking result, ask how large the sample was.
Event 2: Logical Reasoning
Why it ranks near the top. Every day you are handed arguments: in advertising, politics, workplace proposals, and conversation. Logical reasoning is the skill of spotting hidden assumptions, unsupported conclusions, and alternative explanations. It protects you against bad arguments and makes your own reasoning harder to knock down.
Trainability and transfer. Critical-thinking instruction has a large research literature, though effects vary with the teaching method and the outcome measured. A large meta-analysis of critical-thinking instruction found real gains at all educational levels and in all subject areas, with an average effect that is small to moderate.4 Two related papers from one research project on an intensive LSAT course found that Logical Reasoning scores rose, and that participants improved relative to controls on one unpracticed reasoning task, though not on a second one. Because the course covered every section of the test and participants were not randomly assigned, the findings cannot show that Logical Reasoning practice alone caused the gains.5
Where to start:
Work through official LSAT Logical Reasoning questions, and for every miss, write down the assumption or flaw you overlooked.
Learn the common flaw types: confusing correlation with causation, attacking the person instead of the argument, treating a necessary condition as sufficient.
Apply the skill outside the test: take one opinion column a week and identify its conclusion, its evidence, and its weakest assumption.
Tier 2: Reading Comprehension, Mathematical Reasoning, and Scientific Reasoning
Reading comprehension (Event 3) may be the most broadly valuable skill in the decathlon. Almost everything you learn arrives through reading. The catch is that there is no single way to prepare for it. First work out what limits you: vocabulary, background knowledge in the subject, reading strategies, or pacing under time pressure. Then target that. Sustained reading of demanding material helps, especially alongside deliberate practice in summarizing passages, drawing inferences, and noticing when you have lost the thread. If long, complex sentences slow you down, sentence structure may be your bottleneck; see Grammar as a Cognitive Tool: The Extended Writing and Copywriting Stack.
Reading also works as a multiplier. Better reading makes it easier to learn everything else, including statistics, science, and logic, and the ranking does not fully capture that indirect benefit. That is why it leads this tier.
Mathematical reasoning (Event 4) pays off directly in loans, budgets, investments, and work. Its payoff depends heavily on your starting point. If your algebra and percentages are rusty, targeted review is especially worthwhile. If they are already strong, extra GRE-style practice adds less.
Scientific reasoning (Event 6) is the skill of reading graphs and judging what a study actually shows: whether there was a control group, whether a correlation could have another explanation, whether the conclusion goes beyond the data. That matters every time you read a health headline or a research summary. It is related to logical reasoning but not the same: logic asks whether a conclusion follows from its premises, while scientific reasoning asks whether the evidence and methods support the claim. It overlaps with Event 9, so it makes sense to study the two together.
Tier 3: Verbal and Spatial Reasoning
Verbal reasoning (Event 5) depends heavily on vocabulary, which grows through wide reading. That reading also serves Event 3, so the most efficient approach is to prepare for both together, combining wide reading with deliberate vocabulary study where you need it.
Spatial reasoning (Event 7) is the special case in the ranking. It is one of the most trainable abilities in the decathlon: a meta-analysis of more than 200 training studies found that spatial skills improved with practice, that the gains lasted, and that they carried over to untrained spatial tasks.6 It ranks in the middle only because most adults use it less often in daily decisions. For engineers, architects, designers, surgeons, mechanics, and anyone studying a technical field, it belongs near the top.
Tier 4: Abstract Reasoning, Working Memory, and Processing Speed
These three events measure something real, but they are the least worth preparing for.
Abstract reasoning (Event 1). Practicing matrix puzzles makes you better at matrix puzzles. There is little evidence that the improvement carries over to real-world problem solving.
Working memory (Event 8). This has been tested more thoroughly than almost any other form of brain training. Meta-analyses have found that working memory training improves performance on closely related tasks but produces little evidence of broader gains in reasoning, reading, or other skills.7 Working memory itself matters a great deal for complex thinking; the problem is that isolated drills do not carry over.
Processing speed (Event 10). Repeating symbol-matching tasks will make you faster at symbol matching, but there is little evidence that the gain spreads to everyday thinking. One exception is worth knowing. In a large randomized trial of older adults, a structured, adaptive speed-training program produced gains on its targeted abilities that lasted ten years, and trained participants reported less difficulty with daily activities, although objective tests of everyday tasks did not show a significant benefit.8 That was a specialized program, not casual drilling of a test like Digit Symbol Matching. Processing speed also declines with age, so an isolated low score is not diagnostic; interpret it against age norms and your testing conditions.
Take these three tests to complete your profile. For general intellectual development, spend most of your study time elsewhere.
Bonus: divergent thinking. Creativity training does help, though less than often claimed. The largest review of training studies found modest gains on creativity measures once publication bias was taken into account, and too little evidence to say how far those gains extend or how long they last.9 If creativity matters for your work, practice producing actual creative work rather than raising a test score.
When the Answer Changes
The ranking above is for a typical adult with no particular goal. Your own priorities may differ. A Strong result can still be worth more work if the skill matters for your goals, and a Developing result in an area you rarely use may be fine to leave alone.
Combine the ranking with your own profile. Suppose your results were Strong in logical reasoning but Developing in reading comprehension and statistical reasoning. Even though logical reasoning ranks near the top in general, you would probably gain more by working on reading and statistics first, where you have the most room to improve. Study time also has diminishing returns: once a skill is good enough for your purposes, extra hours usually do more good in a weaker area.
- If you work in engineering, design, or another technical field
Move spatial reasoning (Event 7) into the top tier. It is highly trainable and directly relevant.
- If you read research or make health decisions for others
Pair scientific reasoning (Event 6) with statistical reasoning (Event 9). Together they address several of the most common errors in interpreting studies.
- If you are preparing for graduate or law school
Prepare for the test you will actually take. The GRE events (4 and 5) or the LSAT events (2 and 3) become your priority.
- If your math is rusty
Start with mathematical reasoning (Event 4). It is the foundation for Events 6 and 9, and a low starting point leaves the most room to improve.
- If you manage people or make business decisions
Logical reasoning (Event 2) first, then statistical reasoning (Event 9). Proposals, forecasts, and performance data all depend on them.
How to Tell Whether Your Preparation Paid Off
Retaking the same test after studying is a weak check, because you may simply remember the questions. A better test is whether you handle new problems better.
Before you start, collect a set of fresh, practical problems in your target area, such as real health statistics, news arguments, or financial calculations, and record how you do.
After a period of study, try a different set matched as closely as you can for topic, difficulty, scoring, and time limit. If possible, have someone else score both sets without knowing which came first.
Report raw counts along with any percentage. Going from 10 to 12 correct out of 20 is two more right answers, a 10-percentage-point gain in accuracy, and a 20% relative increase. The raw counts are the easiest to interpret.
State the result narrowly. "I answered 12 of 20 unfamiliar probability problems correctly, up from 10, under the same time limit" is a defensible claim. "My statistical intelligence improved by 20%" is not.
Treat a small personal comparison as suggestive, not proof.
For study-hour estimates for each event, see the companion article: How Long Does It Take to Prepare for the Intellectual Decathlon? A Study Plan and Time Budget.
For books on logic, statistics, and forecasting: After the Bootcamp: Reading Plan for Logic, Statistics, Forecasting, Mental Models and Economics.
Conclusion: Train the Skills That Transfer
The decathlon measures ten abilities, but they are not equally worth training. The best investments share three features: you use them often, they respond to study, and the gains carry beyond the practice questions.
For most adults, statistical reasoning and logical reasoning meet all three tests best. They are the skills that most directly protect you from misleading numbers and bad arguments. Reading comprehension, mathematical reasoning, and scientific reasoning follow close behind. Working memory and processing speed are worth measuring, but drilling them is a poor use of study time.
Measure all ten. Train the ones that transfer.
Notes
- Edward T. Cokely, Mirta Galesic, Eric Schulz, Saima Ghazal, and Rocio Garcia-Retamero, "Measuring Risk Literacy: The Berlin Numeracy Test," Judgment and Decision Making 7, no. 1 (2012): 25–47. doi:10.1017/S1930297500001819 ↩
- Geoffrey T. Fong, David H. Krantz, and Richard E. Nisbett, "The Effects of Statistical Training on Thinking About Everyday Problems," Cognitive Psychology 18, no. 3 (1986): 253–292. doi:10.1016/0010-0285(86)90001-0 ↩
- Peter Sedlmeier and Gerd Gigerenzer, "Teaching Bayesian Reasoning in Less Than Two Hours," Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 130, no. 3 (2001): 380–400. doi:10.1037/0096-3445.130.3.380 ↩
- Philip C. Abrami, Robert M. Bernard, Eugene Borokhovski, David I. Waddington, C. Anne Wade, and Tonje Persson, "Strategies for Teaching Students to Think Critically: A Meta-Analysis," Review of Educational Research 85, no. 2 (2015): 275–314. doi:10.3102/0034654314551063 ↩
- Allyson P. Mackey, Alison T. Miller Singley, and Silvia A. Bunge, "Intensive Reasoning Training Alters Patterns of Brain Connectivity at Rest," Journal of Neuroscience 33, no. 11 (2013): 4796–4803, doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4141-12.2013; and Allyson P. Mackey, Alison T. Miller Singley, Carter Wendelken, and Silvia A. Bunge, "Characterizing Behavioral and Brain Changes Associated with Practicing Reasoning Skills," PLOS ONE 10, no. 9 (2015): e0137627, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0137627. ↩
- David H. Uttal, Nathaniel G. Meadow, Elizabeth Tipton, Linda L. Hand, Alison R. Alden, Christopher Warren, and Nora S. Newcombe, "The Malleability of Spatial Skills: A Meta-Analysis of Training Studies," Psychological Bulletin 139, no. 2 (2013): 352–402. doi:10.1037/a0028446 ↩
- Monica Melby-Lervåg and Charles Hulme, "Is Working Memory Training Effective? A Meta-Analytic Review," Developmental Psychology 49, no. 2 (2013): 270–291, doi:10.1037/a0028228; and Monica Melby-Lervåg, Thomas S. Redick, and Charles Hulme, "Working Memory Training Does Not Improve Performance on Measures of Intelligence or Other Measures of 'Far Transfer': Evidence From a Meta-Analytic Review," Perspectives on Psychological Science 11, no. 4 (2016): 512–534, doi:10.1177/1745691616635612. ↩
- George W. Rebok, Karlene Ball, Lin T. Guey, Richard N. Jones, Hae-Young Kim, Jonathan W. King, Michael Marsiske, John N. Morris, Sharon L. Tennstedt, Frederick W. Unverzagt, and Sherry L. Willis, "Ten-Year Effects of the ACTIVE Cognitive Training Trial on Cognition and Everyday Functioning in Older Adults," Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 62, no. 1 (2014): 16–24. doi:10.1111/jgs.12607 ↩
- Ut Na Sio and Hugues Lortie-Forgues, "The Impact of Creativity Training on Creative Performance: A Meta-Analytic Review and Critical Evaluation of 5 Decades of Creativity Training Studies," Psychological Bulletin 150, no. 5 (2024): 554–585. doi:10.1037/bul0000432 ↩
No comments:
Post a Comment